Courageous Conversations: The Shift from Reflex to Reflection

You’ve felt it before, that moment where everything in you wants to speak up, but something holds you back. Maybe it’s fear of conflict, fear of saying the wrong thing, or the worry that you’ll make things worse. And so you hesitate. Or stay silent. Or sugarcoat what really needs to be said.

Here’s the thing: avoiding difficult conversations isn’t leadership, it’s self-protection dressed up as diplomacy.

If there’s one thing leadership research continues to confirm, it’s this: the ability to have courageous conversations is not a soft skill, it’s a strategic necessity.

Harvard Business Review emphasizes that courageous conversations, when followed by clear action, are core to effective leadership. These conversations are ten times more effective at driving real behavioral change than training alone.

It might be the conversation you’ve been putting off with your team lead. Or it might happen tomorrow morning in your kitchen with your teenage daughter. While this article focuses on workplace leadership, everything you’re about to read applies equally to parenting, relationships, and all aspects of life.

In short, avoiding tough conversations doesn’t protect your organization, or family. It limits its growth.

Avoiding them doesn’t build trust, and most importantly, it doesn’t make you a better leader.

Showing up for them does.

Why Are Some Conversations So Difficult?

Let’s name it: some conversations are hard. Not because we’re weak or ill-prepared, but because real communication demands emotional clarity, vulnerability, and presence.

According to Crucial Conversations: Tools for Talking When Stakes Are High, conversations become difficult when three elements collide:

• High Stakes – The outcome matters, often significantly

• Differing Opinions – Conflicting viewpoints surface

• Strong Emotions – Anxiety, anger, or defensiveness take center stage

  
  

When these collide, our nervous system can hijack the moment. We go into fight, flight, freeze, or fawn.

In those states, we often default to two ineffective strategies: silence (avoidance, stonewalling, ghosting, shutting down), or verbal violence (blame, sarcasm, contempt, domination, emotional reactivity).

Every person has a stress response.

One of the first new leadership skills is learning to notice yours.

Your Stress Response: Know It, So It Doesn’t Own You

The amygdala, the ancient part of the brain tasked with survival, gets activated in perceived conflict. It scans for threat, labels quickly, and responds fast. But most modern workplace challenges aren’t life-threatening; they require nuance, not reflex.

When you feel triggered, ask: Where is my energy going now?

Are you obsessing about someone’s behavior? Are you drained by ambivalence or attention-seeking conflict?

Research shows that ambivalence consumes more emotional energy than clarity, even when clarity is difficult.

Learning to observe where your attention and energy go is a powerful leadership move. I write [here] about the courage of being consciously unavailable. Not every issue deserves your energy. You get to choose.

And here's something we rarely give ourselves permission to do: create more space in our inner life.

Space to slow down before we respond. Space to reflect on what’s really happening.

Many of my clients, and I include myself here, find this difficult. But it’s one of the most transformative practices we can develop.

We also have to allow ourselves to change our minds. To say, "I need to take that back," or "I see it differently now that I have more information." This isn’t weakness. It’s growth. It’s leadership.

Start With Yourself

Before you engage with anyone else, pause. Reflect.

Get radically honest with yourself:

• What am I feeling?

• What unmet needs are beneath those feelings?

• What’s my intention in bringing this up?

  
  

Maybe you’re frustrated because your need for innovation is blocked. Maybe you feel hurt because your efforts go unrecognized. Maybe you’re angry because your need for trust and autonomy is unmet.

Do not rush to fix the problem.

First, connect with yourself. Clarity here is your anchor. Once you’re grounded, you can consciously put your needs aside, just long enough to get curious about someone else’s.

Suspend judgment.

Ask better questions. Seek the needs underneath their behavior. If you co-create a solution, the quality, and commitment, will be stronger.

And your relationship? It will grow.

Set Yourself Up to Succeed

• Choose the right moment. Is your calendar spacious enough to have this conversation well? Are you in a mental and emotional state to show up with clarity and presence?

  
  

• Go live. Conversations like this are best done in person, or at least by phone or video. Text or email lacks tone, nuance, and humanity, and crucially, they also bypass the subtle emotional signals that help us co-regulate. They lack the tone of voice, facial expression, and shared presence that help build trust. They also lack the neurochemical magic of oxytocin, a hormone linked to social bonding and empathy, which is released more abundantly during face-to-face connection.

  
  

• Know the complication. What’s the issue you want to raise, and why now? Can you name the tension without blaming or moralizing? Get clear before you speak.

  
  

• Define your intention. What do you hope for, for yourself, for the other person, and for the relationship? What would “success” look like, even if the conversation is hard?

  
  

And remember the old adage: speak about behaviors, not about the person. When you generalize, “You always do this,” or “You are someone who doesn't care”, you trigger defensiveness.

But when you point to a specific behavior, impact, and your experience of it, you keep the conversation grounded in reality and possibility.

By preparing in this way, you’re not scripting the outcome, you’re cultivating the conditions for honesty, respect, and forward movement.

Mind the Narrative

Notice your stories. Our brains are meaning-making machines. When we’re hurt or stressed, we write scripts: She’s always like this. He doesn’t care. They’re just lazy.

Labels kill curiosity.

When you label someone, you stop listening. Dialogue closes. Growth ends.

Instead, lead with questions:

• What might I not be seeing?

• How might this look from their side?

• What’s the need beneath this behavior?

  
  

If you trust your experience and leadership, then you can afford to listen.

Prepare thoughtful questions. Slow your breathing. Regulate your nervous system. Listen with the intention to understand, not to counter.

There are four levels of listening, and most of us hover around level one: listening to confirm. (Otto Scharmer)

Try practicing level four: listening to create.

When You Practice This Way…

Difficult conversations become something else: opportunities for connection, insight, and change.

You build not just strategy, but trust. You address not just symptoms, but systems.

You shift from reactivity to real leadership.

TRY THIS: Courageous Conversation Prep Prompts

• What am I feeling, and what do I need?

• What am I assuming about the other person?

• What story am I telling myself?

• What questions would help me understand their side?

• How can I regulate myself before we talk?

  
  

A Real Story From the Field

A CEO I once coached was preparing for a long-overdue conversation with her operations lead. Tension had been building for months. The CEO saw her colleague as rigid, uncollaborative, and territorial.

When we slowed down, she realized she felt dismissed, like her ideas didn’t matter. Her need for influence and creativity had been stifled. Instead of launching into feedback, she opened the conversation with this:

"I want to better understand how you see our collaboration. I know I’ve been holding some frustration, and I want to name it in service of working better together."

What followed wasn’t easy, but it was honest. And they emerged with more clarity, alignment, and mutual respect.

Want to Take This Further?

I also write [here] about transforming conflict.

If you’re a leader, changemaker, or entrepreneur who wants to elevate your communication and build a culture of trust, reach out. I’d love to help you prepare for the conversations that will shape your future.

Start with yourself. Then show up for the conversation. You might be surprised what opens up.

---

Hi, I’m Monika, Strengths Coach and facilitator. I help individuals and groups cultivate resilience, emotional intelligence, and well-being through strengths-based coaching. Passionate about transformative and creative leadership, I empower leaders to drive meaningful change within themselves, their organizations, and beyond.

I hope you’ll visit often, and I look forward to connecting and working together!