What Got You Here Isn’t the Only Way to Get Here. Rethinking “Fit” Through Strengths-Based Hiring

Great leadership requires humility, it means recognizing that the route you took to success isn’t the only valid route.

When we hire people who solve problems differently, we multiply a team’s creativity, resilience, and results.

After 20 years in global, private, and nonprofit leadership, and another decade as a CliftonStrengths® coach, I’ve watched this principle prove itself again and again.

“Talent is the multiplier. The more energy and attention you invest in it, the greater the yield.”— Gallup, State of the Global Workplace

A Pilot Who Rewrote the Script

During an executive search for a Canadian airline, the client assumed their next star pilot would lead with Focus or Command, straightforward, decisive “cockpit” strengths.

The shortlist said otherwise: a candidate with a flawless 15-year safety record whose #1 talent theme was Individualization.

He treated every flight as singular, a new mix of weather, crew, and personal energy, keeping risk low and performance high.

Had we screened for a narrow “pilot profile,” we’d have missed him entirely, and the reminder that strengths rarely look the way we expect.

What Gallup Actually Advises

Gallup is clear: CliftonStrengths is a development tool, not a pass-fail hiring test. 

Used as a gatekeeper, it invites bias and legal risk.

So how do we leverage strengths ethically to discover game-changing talent?

	Why It Works
Map the team’s existing themes.	Reveals gaps (e.g., heavy Executing, light Strategic Thinking) so you hire complements, not clones.
Train recruiters and managers in strengths language.	Builds self-awareness and surfaces hidden bias before interviews.
Ask strengths-based behavioral questions (“Tell me about a time your natural talents helped you …”).	Elicits real evidence, still - the selection gold standard.
Debrief assessments after hire.	Turns insight into onboarding and engagement gains (Gallup notes boosts of 8–18 %).

Reflection: Which outcomes are slipping because everyone tackles problems the same way? What non-negotiable strengths might be missing?

Strengths-Based Hiring & Busting Your Own Bias

1. Name it. Which of your talents do you unconsciously reward in others?

2. Challenge it. How could a different theme reach the same goal?

3. Partner up. Invite a colleague with opposite talents to co-interview; they’ll spot value you might dismiss.

   
   

Strengths are not a formula; they’re a language to describe how you think, act and connect with others.

Where Strengths Truly Shine in Recruitment

• Team-intelligence hiring. Scaling innovation? Intentionally add Strategic-Thinking themes.

• Role evolution. A job pivoting toward partnership may thrive on Relationship-Building talents.

• Culture clarity. Sharing the team map with finalists signals transparency and sparks richer dialogue about their unique contribution.

  
  

Reflection: How might your culture change if every new hire expanded, rather than duplicated, your collective talent set?

Gallup’s meta-analysis shows that organizations intentionally developing natural talents see up to 29 % higher profit, 15 % higher engagement, and 7 % higher customer metrics.

Those gains begin with how we bring people in, yet many selection processes, instead of  on strengths-based hiring, still reward candidates who simply mirror the leadership team.

Humility in hiring means accepting that the path that carried you to success is not the only valid route.

When we recruit for diversity of talent instead of likeness, we don’t just fill roles, we future-proof our organizations.

Ready to Experiment?

Remember:

• CliftonStrengths ≠ crystal ball. Use it after validating skills and values, not instead of them.

• Diversity of talent fuels sustainability. Homogeneous strengths drive short-term efficiency but long-term fragility.

• Humility is strategic. What got you here isn’t the only way, and hiring with that mindset unlocks performance you can’t yet imagine.

  
  

If you’re curious about mapping your team’s unseen strengths, designing bias-resistant interviews, or turning new-hire debriefs into engagement accelerators, let’s talk.

Strengths, applied well, are one of the most energizing ways to lift creativity, well-being, and results, together.

---

Hi, I’m Monika, Strengths Coach and facilitator. I help individuals and groups cultivate resilience, emotional intelligence, and well-being through strengths-based coaching. Passionate about transformative and creative leadership, I empower leaders to drive meaningful change within themselves, their organizations, and beyond.

I hope you’ll visit often, and I look forward to connecting and working together!